Hit while riding without a helmet and told you get only half? Fault comes first; any cut is up to the court
No helmet does not make you the one at fault. Head injuries may cut damages (Civil Code 217), case by case. What to claim, compulsory insurance, mediation.
You are riding without a helmet when a car breaks the rules and hits you, and the other driver says that since you had no helmet, they will pay only half your medical bills. In fact, fault for the accident depends first on who broke the rules and caused it; not wearing a helmet does not make you the one who caused the crash. But if your injury is to the head, a court may find you contributed to the harm and reduce part of the damages; how much is decided by the court case by case, not by the other side. Separately, riding without a helmet carries a NT$500 fine.
01Step 1: deal with the scene, get checked and keep evidence
Look after your body first, then the evidence. You will need all of it later to claim damages and compulsory insurance.
- Call 110 for the police, and 119 if anyone is hurt.
- Get examined at a hospital and ask for a medical certificate (診斷證明書).
- Photograph the scene, the vehicle damage and the other vehicle's plate.
- Write down witnesses' names and phone numbers.
02Step 2: fault depends on who broke the rules, not the helmet
Who caused the accident depends on who broke the rules: running a red light, failing to yield, speeding. Not wearing a helmet does not make you the one who caused it.
- 30 days after the accident, you can apply to the police bureau that handled it for the preliminary accident analysis (道路交通事故初步分析研判表).
- It sets out the police's initial view of the cause, which helps when you negotiate compensation.
- National Police Agency — Apply to the police unit that handled the accident
03Step 3: what you can claim
Civil Code Article 184 is the general rule on liability for wrongful acts; Article 191-2 makes the driver of a car or motorcycle in use liable for harm it causes. Losses from bodily injury fall under Article 193, and pain and suffering under Article 195.
- Medical costs.
- Nursing care costs.
- Lost earnings while you cannot work.
- Motorcycle repair costs.
- Compensation for pain and suffering (精神慰撫金).
04Step 4: contributory fault depends on whether the injury is linked to the helmet
Civil Code Article 217: where the victim contributed to causing or worsening the harm, the court may reduce or remove the damages. Riding without a helmet can make a head injury worse, so with a head injury the court may reduce part of the damages.
- Head injury: the court may reduce part of the damages because you had no helmet.
- Injuries unrelated to the head (for example a broken leg): usually unaffected.
- How much is cut is decided by the court case by case; the other side cannot simply declare half.
05Step 5: claim compulsory insurance first
Compulsory automobile liability insurance is basic protection for victims and is no-fault (Compulsory Automobile Liability Insurance Act Article 7): it does not depend on whether you were at fault.
- Apply to the other vehicle's compulsory insurer.
- Injury medical costs are covered up to NT$200,000.
- Prepare the medical certificate, medical receipts and the accident records.
- Motor Vehicle Accident Compensation Fund — Compulsory insurance information, and claims when the other vehicle is uninsured or cannot be found
06Step 6: no agreement? Mediate first, then sue
- Mediate at the district office mediation committee (區公所調解委員會), free of charge.
- If mediation fails, file a small-claims or civil lawsuit.
- Legal Aid Foundation, 412-8518.
A district office mediation that succeeds and is approved by the court has the same effect as a final civil judgment (Township and County-Administered City Mediation Act Article 27).
07Step 7: no helmet is a separate fine
Road Traffic Management and Penalty Act Article 31(6): if a motorcycle rider or passenger does not wear a helmet as required, the rider is fined NT$500.
- You have no helmet: the rider is fined NT$500.
- Your passenger has no helmet: the rider is fined too.
08Things to watch
- There is no fixed percentage for contributory fault; the court looks at how the injury relates to the missing helmet, case by case.
- An accident is not always one side's fault; if you also broke a rule (say, ran a red light or sped), you may be found partly at fault for that too.
- A damages claim must be made within 2 years of learning of the harm and who is liable (Civil Code Article 197); do not wait.
- Do not rush to sign a settlement that waives all other claims before your injuries settle; once signed you usually cannot ask for more.
Sources
What should we explain next?
Every reel has a full guide. Follow @lawbao.tw and check here first before you decide whether you need a lawyer.
TrialAI
Want to know how your case would go?
TrialAI runs an AI mock trial and predicts the outcome. Describe your situation and see your odds before you decide what to do next.


